home | history home page | gallery | brock james |
![]() |
Clermont punish Wasps' bravery
|
![]() |
![]() |
Clermont claim the upper hand
Saturday 8th December 2007
From: planet-rugby (http://planet-rugby.com/Story/0,18259,3551_2954776,00.html)

James Haskell: Makes the most of some weak Clermont defence to score
Clermont capitalised on several moments of Wasps ill-discipline to send the
Heineken Cup champions home empty-handed on Saturday, in a rugged 37-27 victory
in the Heineken Cup.
Wasps were punished for a gamble in the dying throes of a enthralling game. There will be those who argue it was a needless gamble, and those who commend Wasps' adventure, but let's reserve judgement until the end of this gripping pool, as only then will the true value of a missed bonus point become clear. Truth be known, this defeat was born out of the Wasps' own indiscipline, the sort that crept into their game as early as the second minute and from then on the rot spread. Six of those infringements were punished by the impeccable boot of Brock James, but there were several more in less advantageous positions. There will also be no doubt that Wasps will look to one critical moment in the game, the sort of moment that a game, and in this case a pool, can hinge on. Patient approach work from Clermont created the space on the blind side for the tenacious Mario Ledesma, who in turn dipped his shoulder and bullocked over for what seemed a perfectly legitimate score. Several television replays showed that the hooker clearly failed to score, James Haskell's despairing boot preventing the grounding before Mark Van Gisbergen wrestled the ball from Ledesma's failing grip. Yet the TMO controversially awarded the try to deal the champions a devastating blow on the stroke of half time.
An opening quarter that stumbled along will be remembered for three penalties, two for James and one for Danny Cipriani, and little else. Both sides looked to wrestle control from the other, only to achieve a stalemate that threatened to spoil the spectacle. Then, against the flow of the game, Clermont struck in superb fashion. A midfield scrum allowed them to probe the blind side through Pierre Mignoni and then Marius Joubert. It was Joubert who attracted the Wasps cover defenders before slipping a dreamy pass back into Julien Malzieu who did the rest.
Wasps, on the ropes, flexed their muscle and hit back with a score of their own, although Sam Broomhall and Julien Bonnaire will rather forget the incident altogether. Haskell took up possession of the ball faced with the formidable back row pair and set his direction straight at them. Contact was taken and somehow Haskell emerged on the other side with a simple route to the line. Broomhall and Bonnaire were left clutching at thin air.
It was then, as Wasps looked to claim a footing in the game, that Ledesma scored to open up a telling gap at the interval. It was a gap that Wasps had little regard for, taking just a minute of the second half to cut it by seven, Tim Payne finishing off a fine flowing move. The indiscipline then began to eat away at the very core of Wasps, Brock James slotting the first of four second-half penalties from straight in front. Haskell did help himself to a second score, thanks largely to the one poor Clermont line-out of the game, nonetheless it was a try that swung the lead the way of the champions for the first time.
Knowing that they had a chance to consolidate their favourable position Wasps proceeded to surrender their lead inside a minute, this time Phil Vickery the guilty party, not for the first or last time. Two successful penalties from James soon become three when Simon Shaw was caught offside, and then three became four with Vickery's idiotic stamp on the prone Thibaut Privat.
Staring the prospect of going home empty-handed in the face Wasps were thrown a lifeline after Malzieu was caught with his hands in the cookie jar at the ruck. Cipriani shouldered the pressure - he had failed twice before - and delivered the required result with a fine kick. Time for Wasps to chance their arm, one sensed. Indeed they did chance their arm and it cost them dear, as it was when they desperately went after a winning score that the ball was lost and Aurélien Rougerie ran away with a try, the game, and Wasps' precious bonus-point.
Man of the match: For Wasps there was the dynamic Raphaël Ibañez and outstanding James Haskell, but it was the Clermont players who stole the show. Mario Ledesma was immense, turning in a vintage performance, but it was his fly-half Brock James who steals the award from him. It was his boot that won this game, primarily the points it contributed but also the manner in which he pinned Wasps back time and again.
The scorers:
For Clermont: Try: Malzieu, Ledesma, Rougerie, Cons: James 2,Pens: James 6
For Wasps:Tries: Haskell 2, Payne, Cons: Cipriani 3, Pens: Cipriani 2
The Teams:
Clermont Auvergne: 15 Anthony Floch, 14 Aurélien Rougerie (c), 13
Marius Joubert, 12 Gonzalo Canale, 11 Julien Malzieu, 10 Brock James, 9 Pierre
Mignoni, 8 Elvis Vermeulen, 7 Sam Broomhall, 6 Julien Bonnaire, 5 Thibaut Privat,
4 Jamie Cudmore, 3 Martin Scelzo, 2 Mario Ledesma, 1 Laurent Emmanuelli.
Replacements: 16 Mirko Lozupone, 17 Thomas Domingo, 18 Christophe Samson, 19
Alexandre Audebert, 20 John Senio, 21 Alex King, 22 Benoît Baby.
London Wasps: 15 Mark Van Gisbergen, 14 Paul Sackey, 13 Fraser Waters,
12 Riki Flutey, 11 Tom Voyce, 10 Danny Cipriani, 9 Eoin Reddan, 8 Lawrence
Dallaglio (c), 7 James Haskell, 6 John Hart, 5 George Skivington, 4 Simon Shaw,
3 Phil Vickery, 2 Raphael Ibanez, 1 Tim Payne.
Replacements: 16 Rob Webber, 17 Nick Adams, 18 Richard Birkett, 19 Dan Leo, 20
Simon Amor, 21 Josh Lewsey, 22 Tom Rees.
Referee: Alan Lewis (Ireland)
Touch judges: George Clancy (Ireland), Dudley Phillips (Ireland)
"I feel like a traitor" were Alex King's first words in an interview with an English newspaper on Monday, as he was caught coming out of a pre-match briefing with his new coaches in France. The reason? The briefing had been supposedly given by King himself, as the fly-half prepares to face up to his former Wasps team-mates in the colours of his new club Clermont Auvergne in the Heineken Cup on Saturday. ............... "I must say I'm looking forward to going back to Adams Park because I didn't really get a chance to say goodbye to a number of the players and fans. I've already been having some banter with Lawrence Dallaglio on the phone and it should be a very special game.
Not that he is guaranteed a starting spot either. Clermont are blessed with
riches in most positions, and fly-half is no exception, with Australian Brock
James currently ruling the roost at the Stade Marcel Michelin. "I
have not been able to get a starting place yet, but it was always going to be
difficult getting in ahead of Brock James," he said.
"He is a class act and has become very important to the side. I'm still
learning patterns of play and strategies - although I'm sure I'll be used to
give an insight into the Wasps game plan.
"I'm surprised more English players haven't tried their luck in France," he said. "It improves your perspective on the game and life. It is a fantastic contrast to playing in England and it helps you to find out more about yourself by removing you from your comfort zone."

Pivotal: Brock James supplied a try, four conversions and a penalty to
Clermont's tally
Clermont Auvergne opened their Heineken cup campaign with an impressive 48-21
bonus-point victory over the Scarlets at Stade Marcel Michelin on Sunday.
Last season's Challenge Cup winners made the step up to the top-flight of Europe
with consummate ease and raced away to an early lead in a pulsating game. Julien
Bonnaire's try just after half-time wrapped up the bonus point before the
Scarlets rallied with two tries in as many minutes. But any hopes of a comeback
were quashed soon after as Aurélien Rougerie completed his hat-trick and Brock
James scored a well-earned try.
It seems fitting that this fine opening weekend of European rugby ending with a ten-try cracker packed with more action and adventure than a teenager's dream weekend. Much was expected from the clash between these two attack-oriented sides and they didn't disappoint. Indeed, referee Chris White was reduced to a mere onlooker for all but the opening period as passes stuck and off-loads were collected. But not even the Scarlets would complain about the final score - Clermont were deserving winners and must now be considered favourites to crowd European champions come the end of May. Whilst the Scarlets' take on free-flowing rugby looked laboured, Clermont's players were surely born to run with ball in hand - and they are mighty clever, too. James and Pierre Mignoni made all the right decisions behind an obedient pack and the backline made cunning use of the decoy-runner.
First points came early and from the back of collapsed scrum. The nod went the home side's way, and James made no mistake off the tee. Stephen Jones then decided to maintain friendly relations with his former fan-base by pumping a kickable penalty into the corner. But, in a harbinger of things to come, the advantage was lost to some over-elaborate inter-passing in the wake of the line-out.
Anthony Floch, Clermont's long-range marksman, was the next man at the tee after Rougerie was molested off the ball, but his effort fell well short. Yet the missed kick mattered not one wit. From the drop-out, Jones took an age before deciding to send out a long pass, and Rougerie collective the gift and galloped in for an opportune try. James added the extras and Clermont were 10-0 up with 16 minutes played.
The local fans had hardly settled back into the seats before Regan King had danced down the right, shrugging off three tackles before feeding Dafydd James, and the Wales wing dotted down in the corner as he has so often before. Jones added the tricky conversion and suddenly we had a free-flowing fiesta on our hands. Cheeky skills started to break out all over the field, with varying degrees of success. A fumble in defence from the visitors lead to a scrum outside the red 22 and James threaded a beautiful grubber into the path of Julien Malzieu, and the France hopeful beat his opposite number to touch down for an unconverted try. And before the Scarlets could steady themselves, Clermont had their third.
Alexandre Audebert showed great composure as he made a trundling break down the right, selling a dummy before drawing the defence and sending Rougerie free. There was a hint of a double movement as the big France star twisted across the line, but the video referee confirmed that the Welsh visitors were in big trouble. Despite the succession of sucker punches, the Scarlets kept true to their game-plan, keeping the ball alive and in hand wherever and whenever possible. But Clermont's superior handling skill laid the seeds of doubt in Welsh heads, and Alix Popham highlighted the growing frustrations with an armless tackle on a ball-less player.
From the ensuing penalty, Clermont decided to switch tactics and sparked up a series of rolling mauls. How close they got on a number of occassion, but how well the Scarlets defended their line, proving they have the physicality to match any side in the competition. Yellow wave after yellow wave was repelled, with King and Matthew Watkins to the fore, and the siege was finally lifted by the whistle signalling the end of the first half. But bravery in defence does not win matches, particularly when you find yourself pinned to your sticks and 13 points adrift at the break. The Scarlets were in a sizable hole, and the home crowd knew it.
The visitors started the second half in a positive mood, sending their big men at the French fringes. But Clermont pounced as Welsh hands broke down out wide. In came the support players and Mignoni shepherded Julien Bonnaire over the line. With the half barely three minutes old, the home side already had their bonus point, and James added the conversion for good measure. As the drums sounded up around Stade Marcel Michelin, the awful truth hit home for the Welsh: only a superhuman fightback could save them from the ignominy of returning home with nothing to show from their travels.
To their credit, they made a good fist of the response, managing to set up camp in the home side's half. Suddenly, Dwayne Peel rounded the back of a red line-out on the yellow 22 and jinxed his way to the line past a flummoxed set of Clermont backs - not a finger touched him. Jones added the conversion as the French crowd fell silent. Peel's moment of individual brilliance sparked the Scarlets back to life and Jones was soon lining up another conversion as King got on the end of slick move that came sprawling out of their own half. Jones converted his kick and suddenly the sides were just seven points apart. But the hosts refused to panic. A chip ahead from James soon had them planted on the red line. The ball was moved right and Rougerie showed great strength to power past two tacklers to score.
James secured the extras before adding a try to his impressive tally, finishing off a simple move by taking Mignoni's pass on the short side. Another conversion from the Australian fly-half duly followed and suddenly we were back to where we were just ten short minutes before, with the Scarlets trailing by 20 points. Clermont were enjoying life again, and the appearance off the bench of South Africa captain John Smit and former Wasps pivot Alex King would have put the wind up the Welsh.
With the Englishman now kicking for territory, it was left to Clermont's forwards to deliver the coup de grace, and Thomas Domingo rumbled over the whitewash from the tail of a line-out for his side's seventh and final try before King opened his French account with the conversion. Coming back from the brink is feasible, but doing it twice in a game is beyond the capabilities of most teams - and so it was for the Scarlets. With the game gone but with that all-important fourth try still dangling within their grasps, they threw body and soul into the last ten minutes of the game, but Clermont held them back with equal ferociously.
Points will surely decided the fate of the four sides unlucky enough to find themselves in Pool Five, and the first round of action seems to have already offered up a candidate for sacrifice: whilst Munster snatched a point off Wasps, the Scarlets return home with nothing. It's an early and harsh assessment, but that's the horrible beauty of this wonderful tournament. If you want happy endings for all, move below the equator.
Man of the match: Regan King and Alix Popham kept Welsh fires burning from start to finish, but this award will remain here in France. Aurélien Rougerie came looking for work and was duly rewarded with a hat-trick. Julien Bonnaire did the dirty work in the tight and Pierre Mignoni pulled all the right stings from scrum-half, but it is Brock James who takes the spoils for an intelligent performance in which he hardly put a foot wrong.
The scorers:
For Clermont Auvergne: Tries: Rougerie 3, Malzieu, Bonnaire, James, Domingo
Cons: James 4, King Pen: James
For Scarlets: Tries: D James, Peel, King Cons: S Jones 3
The teams:
Clermont Auvergne: 15 Anthony Floch, 14 Aurélien Rougerie (c), 13 Gonzalo Canale, 12 Seremaïa Bai, 11 Julien Malzieu, 10 Brock James, 9 Pierre Mignoni, 8 Elvis Vermeulen, 7 Alexandre Audebert, 6 Julien Bonnaire, 5 Thibaut Privat, 4 Loic Jacquet, 3 Martín Scelzo, 2 Mario Ledesma, 1 Laurent Emmanuelli. Replacements: 16 John Smit, 17 Thomas Domingo, 18 Christophe Samson, 19 Emmanuel Etien, 20 Arnaud Pic, 21 Pierre-Manuel Garcia, 22 Vilimoni Delasau.
Scarlets: 15 Morgan Stoddart, 14 Dafydd James, 13 Regan King, 12 Gavin Evans, 11 Matthew Watkins, 10 Stephen Jones, 9 Dwayne Peel (c), 8 Alix Popham, 7 Gavin Thomas, 6 James Bater, 5 Scot MacLeod, 4 Vernon Cooper, 3 Deacon Manu, 2 Matthew Rees, 1 Iestyn Thomas. Replacements: 16 James Hayter, 17 Bruce Douglas, 18 Adam Eustace, 19 Dafydd Jones, 20 Gavin Cattle, 21 Rhys Priestland, 22 Garan Evans.
Referee: Chris White (England) Touch judges: Ashley Rowden (England), Paul Dix (England)
Courtesy .... www.planetrugby.com
CLERMONT Auvergne survived a spirited fightback from Bath to win the European
Challenge Cup for the second time at Twickenham Stoop today (AEST).
The French trailed 3-6 at the break but clinched a 22-16 victory with tries from
Julien Malzieu, Tony Marsh and Brock James.
Clermont had dominated play but lacked efficiency in finishing, letting four
potential tries slip through its fingers before the break.
Bath lead at half-time thanks to penalties from England fly-half Olly Barkley
after 13 and 37 minutes.
A try from winger Joe Maddock, converted by Barkley, lifted Bath spirits and
only the video referee stopped Clermont conceding when Peter Short reached over.
Barkley kicked his third penalty of the night in the dying minutes off the game
but could not reduce the deficit.
"We were probably lucky to come away with a win, to be honest,"
said Clermont's New Zealand centre, Tony Marsh. "There was desperate
defending there at the end."
Bath captain Steve Borthwick added: "Courageous effort at the end. I'm
proud of the boys. It hurts to lose any final but we've got to learn from it -
we need to start from minute one - and come back stronger next season."
Clermont reclaimed the title it last won in 1999 and broke an English stranglehold on the event going back to 2001.
.. Agence France-Presse
With thanks to 'Coach', of Western Force, for the picture below.


Click on the image below to enlarge it ....
Taken in January 2007 during Clermont's win over
Castres. Brock scored 17 points.
With thanks to Frenchy-ASM of Clermont-Ferrand for the photographs











home | history home page | gallery | brock james |
| Contact: Paul Horne | |
| URL: www.oldcollegiansrugby.org.au | |